Why no Umbraco on Aaron-Powell.com?

8 April 2010 · 3 minute read · umbraco · blogging · paulpad

So unsurprisingly I’ve had a few people question why I’m not using Umbraco for the latest version of Aaron-Powell.com.

First off let’s just have a look back on my blogging and the blog engines I’ve used.

Back before I was the world-famous blogger that I am today I used Windows Live Spaces for blogging, yeah, I was just that awesome. But when I decided to buy my own domain I thought it was only appropriate that I started using some actual software.

I chose Umbraco, which was in version 3 at the time (this was somewhere around August 2008) which wasn’t too bad at the time.

I installed Warren Buckley’s Creative Web Starter kit which was available at the time. Last year when I met him and he had a look I think he was shocked at just how old a version of it I was running! I had a pretty basic skin on it, which err, was ok (ha!).

Next I installed the Blog 4 Umbraco package (version 1) which I then rewrote the front end controls for it.

By now I was not really using OOTB other than the document types (which I’d also hacked a bit) and it was starting to become a bit of a mess. But I kept with it, I did a major overhaul of it when I produced the LINQ to Umbraco training videos.

And this brings us to the present day. Although my Umbraco site did do what I needed it to do, but I’m never content, so I was looking for the next round of improvements. Since MVC is completely the sex I decided that I wanted to use that as a blogging platform. Now it is true that I could have used Umbraco still, but I don’t really have the time to re-write the front end yet again! :P

This is why I chose PaulPad, that and I really liked the OOTB style of the site. Essentially it brought all of what I was looking for in a code base to me with very little work needed.

Something else really appealing about PaulPad is that this is actually much less of a blogging platform than it is a wiki platform. Something I had noticed on my Umbraco blogging engine was that it wasn’t great if I wanted to go back and revise a post and have it very obvious. With more of a wiki feel it’s easier to do that. Also, there’s a lot more transparency over the revision history, which will be handy with some upcoming topics.

Lastly, I believe that if you are going to be able to truly evangalise a platform (ie - Umbraco) you can’t just use it. You need to be familiar with your competitors (although PaulPad is hardly a competitor :P), so this is a good way to really just play with something that’s not Umbraco.

Hopefully that sheds some light on my madness regarding my dismissal of Umbraco as my choice of blogging platform.


Published: 2017-07-30 20:47:37 +1000 +1000, Version: bfd8bbd